Chef's Summary
- Prepare an umami-rich stock from roasted chicken bones, classic mirepoix, and whole peppercorns
- Make traditional mashed potatoes by boiling and mashing until smooth
- Build a pepper gravy by starting with a roux, then whisking in the stock and finely ground pepper
- Serve generously finished with freshly ground pepper
This recipe takes time, care, and patience to create the most delicious peppery mashed potatoes. Original post on Instagram here.
Ingredients:
- 600g-1kg russet potatoes
- 4 tbsp butter (about half a block)
- 2 tbsp all purpose flour
- chicken bones (or other bones)
- 2 carrots, 2 celery stalks , 1 onion
- 5-10g of whole peppercorns
Part 1: Prep Chicken Stock
- Loosely chop (medium to large dice) carrots, celery, onions into chunks
- Lightly oil and roast veggies with chicken bones in the oven at approx 375 °C for 15-20 min or until dry and brown
Alternative: roast in a pan with oil or butter on Medium-High to create browning flavor on stove
- Boil 500mL of water in a pot with 1/2 teaspoon of salt
- Add bones and roasted veggies with a palm full of Debut Blend peppercorns (~8-15)
- Boil for 20min and then strain the veggie / bone scraps
- Incorporate finely ground black pepper into the stock
- Simmer at medium-low for 20m to reduce stock to half (approx 250mL)

- Stock is done
Part 2: Mash the Potatoes
- Peel 600g-1kg of russet potatoes
- Chop each potato into 6-8 similarly sized pieces

- Boil 2L of water and add 1 tbsp of salt
- Add potato chunks and boil for 15-20min until you can poke a fork through
- Strain and save 50-100mL of the starchy water to re-add later
- Mash the potatoes with whatever tools you have until... well... mash
- Add 2 tbsp of butter (get the best one you can) and fold into the potatoes

- Slowly add in the "starchy water," ~10-20mL at a time until you get your desired fluffiness
- Mashed potatoes are done
Part 3: Pepper Gravy Galore
- Take 2 tbsp of butter and start browning it in a small pot on medium heat
- Lower heat, whisk in 2 tbsp of AP flour and incorporate the mixture together (this is called a "roux")

- Add in 50mL of your heavenly stock into the roux, continue to whisk
- Keep adding in stock until you achieve the desired thickness
Quick test: gravy on a spoon; draw a line with your finger - if the gravy doesn't move on the spoon, it's thick enough
- Gravy is done
Plating Tips
- Plate the potatoes like a mountain range with different peaks and valleys so that the gravy will catch to different parts
- Generously ladle gravy all over the plate
- Finish with freshly ground medium coarse black pepper

Voilà - enjoy your Pepper Gravy Mashed Potatoes!